top of page
The Cousins Report
In re L.E.S.
2026 - Ohio - 1449 (Apr. 28, 2026) (DeWine, J.; Brunner, J., concurring in judgment only) Holding. R.C. 3111.95(A), the non-spousal artificial insemination statute, reaches only married couples; a court may not apply it to an unmarried same-sex couple on a finding that they would have married but for Ohio’s former ban (¶ 4, 19, 23-25).' Takeaways. For an unmarried nonbiological partner, consider whether a shared-custody agreement is available; the concurrence treated the R.C.
1 min read
J.E.S. v. A.S.
2026 - Ohio - 458 (8th Dist. Feb. 12, 2026) (Boyle, P.J.) Holding. No mandate issues when the Supreme Court of Ohio declines a jurisdictional appeal, S.Ct.Prac.R. 18.04(D), so the trial court had jurisdiction to act on remand two days after the declination (¶ 12-13). Takeaways. When the Supreme Court declines review, the remand can proceed at once, and a later docketing date bought no extra time here.
1 min read
S.T.C. v. J.P.C.
2026 - Ohio - 3880 (8th Dist. Oct. 1, 2026) (S. Gallagher, J.) Holding. A trial court may refuse to consider a transcript filed late and without leave, and without a timely transcript both the trial court and the court of appeals are bound by the magistrate’s findings (section II.A). Takeaways. A transcript filed late and without leave may be disregarded, leaving the magistrate’s findings in place; here it came weeks after the supplemental objections, with no explanation offe
1 min read
Suwareh v. Nwankwo
2026 - Ohio - 2225 (12th Dist. June 15, 2026) (Hendrickson, P.J.) Holding. Under Butler County Domestic Relations Loc.R. 1(F), objections submitted to the court’s Case Management Office within 14 days but filed with the clerk on day 26 were untimely, leaving only plain error review (¶ 14, fn. 1). Takeaways. A submission to the court’s Case Management Office did not count as a filing here; filing objections with the clerk within 14 days may avoid the problem.
1 min read
O’Neal v. Reeves
2026 - Ohio - 2836 (10th Dist. July 23, 2026) (Jamison, J.) Holding. Filing the hearing transcripts without objections preserves nothing: the party waives all but plain error, and the court will not find plain error she does not argue and the record does not show (¶ 15, 17, 19-20). Takeaways. Transcripts filed without objections preserved nothing here; the court described the sequence as objections first, with the transcript filed in support afterward.
1 min read
Jackson v. Tyler
2026 - Ohio - 1435 (10th Dist. Apr. 21, 2026) (Leland, J.) Holding. A party who files no objections under Juv.R. 40(D)(3)(b)(iv) waives all but plain error, must assert plain error in the assignments, and cannot rely on a transcript the trial court did not have (¶ 6-8). Takeaways. A transcript the trial judge did not have does little on appeal; filing it with timely objections puts it before the court that can use it.
1 min read
Hood v. Hood
2026 - Ohio - 1666 (10th Dist. May 7, 2026) (per curiam) Holding. A party must object within 14 days even when the court adopts the magistrate’s decision the day it is filed (¶ 7). Without objections or a plain error argument, an appellant forfeits his arguments (¶ 8). Takeaways. The 14-day objection period ran even though the judge adopted the decision the same day; timely objections, with a transcript for factual issues, may keep the arguments available.
1 min read
Ryan v. Ryan
2026 - Ohio - 3600 (10th Dist. Sept. 15, 2026) (Mentel, J.) Holding. Orders entered after the notice of appeal are outside that appeal (¶ 24); a timely notice is the only jurisdictional requirement (¶ 22, fn. 2); a due process bias claim requires a prior affidavit of disqualification when one could be filed (¶ 50). Takeaways. Exhibits not moved into evidence, a bias claim without an affidavit of disqualification, and orders entered after the notice of appeal all fell outside
1 min read
Mahbub v. Mahbub
2025 - Ohio - 5867 (10th Dist. Dec. 31, 2025) (Mentel, J.) Holding. App.R. 12(C) lets a court of appeals render custody judgment on a manifest weight finding, though Miller v. Miller, 37 Ohio St.3d 71 (1988), bars that for mere abuse of discretion (¶ 14, 61-64). An unadmitted post-trial GAL report could not be considered (¶ 25). Takeaways. When a guardian ad litem report arrives after trial, consider asking that it be offered, admitted, and subject to cross-examination before
1 min read
Weilbacher v. Weilbacher
2026 - Ohio - 3646 (10th Dist. Sept. 17, 2026) (Boggs, P.J.) Holding. A custody change resting on father’s brief, uncontested testimony was against the manifest weight of the evidence, and the court rendered judgment under App.R. 12(C) reinstating the 2019 agreed shared parenting plan (¶ 31, 34-36). Reversed, without remand. Takeaways. Even at an uncontested custody hearing, consider offering evidence on each R.C. 3109.04(F) factor; in the Tenth District, a manifest weight as
1 min read
Seelbaugh v. Montgomery Cty. Court of Common Pleas, Domestic Relations Div.
2025 - Ohio - 5297 (Dec. 2, 2025) (per curiam) Holding. Objections to a magistrate’s contempt decision under Civ.R. 53(D)(3)(b), followed by appeal, are an adequate remedy that defeats prohibition, and a domestic relations division cannot be sued (¶ 8, 23-24). Trust-based sovereign-citizen arguments do not defeat jurisdiction (¶ 14). Takeaways. A magistrate’s contempt decision is ordinarily challenged by objection and appeal, and a writ aimed at one may fail for that reason a
1 min read
E.A.K.M. v. M.A.M.
2025 - Ohio - 2946 (Aug. 21, 2025) (DeWine, J.; Kennedy, C.J., concurring in judgment only) Holding. Finality is decided by category of order, and an interlocutory order to pay guardian ad litem fees in a pending divorce and custody case is not final under R.C. 2505.02(B)(2) (¶ 21-23, 26). Court of appeals’ judgment vacated. Decided before October 1, 2025. Takeaways. Because review of an interim fee order generally waits for the final judgment, consider paying under protest a
1 min read
Eggleston v. Wood
2025 - Ohio - 5292 (Nov. 26, 2025) (Kennedy, C.J.)
1 min read
Separate Beds, Joint Books
M.K.F. v. A.S.F., 2026-Ohio-2540 (8th Dist.), decided July 2, 2026, Case No. 115454.
2 min read
Sliding Doors
The Supreme Court of Ohio reversed the First District's remand order asking whether a same-sex couple 'would have been married' before Obergefell. P.S. bore three children through artificial inseminat
2 min read
The Purge: Logan County
Whitman v. Whitman, 2026-Ohio-406 (3d Dist., Logan County), decided February 9, 2026, Case No. 8-24-47
2 min read
Death Was Never the Deal
A.M. v. J.M., 2026-Ohio-2532 (8th Dist.), decided July 2, 2026, Case Nos. 114462 and 114488
2 min read
bottom of page